COVID-19 Latest
World|opinion & analysis|August 27, 2015 / 01:12 PM
Pentagon launches investigation into claims against intelligence manipulating data about IS

AKIPRESS.COM - ISIS At least since the revelation that the information presented by the United States intelligence community in the lead-up to the Iraq War was grossly wrong, the assessments compiled by the various agencies have been seen with a more skeptical eye, Deutsche Welle reports.

The U.S. Defense Department's Inspector General has launched an inquiry into allegations that intelligence about the campaign against the militant group Islamic State was distorted to provide a rosier picture. The manipulated information included assessments provided for President Barack Obama.

"That some people are claiming that intelligence reports were skewed before being passed on to policymakers is very worrying," said Charlie Winter, a senior researcher with counter-extremism think tank the Quilliam Foundation.

While the Pentagon has not issued an official reaction as to the accuracy of the report which was published online Tuesday, it seems likely it would have done so had the story been erroneous.

Regardless of whether the investigation finds any wrongdoing, the incident highlights once again the inherent difficulties of providing and verifying intelligence.

"Someone told me once it is like a three-dimensional chess game underwater with all the pieces moving simultaneously," said Magnus Ranstorp, a terrorism expert at Sweden's National Defense College. "It is very difficult to see the whole picture and the flows and the dynamics between the different areas."

What's more, said Elie Tenenbaum, a security analyst at the French Institute of International Relations, it is not uncommon that different services conducting their own analyses arrive at different conclusions. "If you look deep enough you always find contradictory assessments coming from intelligence agencies. It is not a hard science."

Still, the Obama administration's approach of probing whether intelligence was skewed positively differentiates it from the way the Bush administration handled the intelligence failure over Iraq's alleged weapons of mass destructions, noted the experts.

While the picture provided by U.S. and other intelligence services about the self-proclaimed Islamic State's rise and strength has not been entirely inaccurate, there is certainly room for improvement.

"Intelligence estimations of the Islamic State's power and sustainability in Iraq and Syria have been varied at best and badly wrong at worst," said Winter. "So I can see why there is this investigation being made."

In order to bolster the quality and reliability of the information they provide, said the experts, U.S. and Western intelligence services collectively must do better at fusing their individual research to create a unified picture.

All rights reserved

© AKIpress News Agency - 2001-2024.

Republication of any material is prohibited without a written agreement with AKIpress News Agency.

Any citation must be accompanied by a hyperlink to akipress.com.

Our address:

299/5 Chingiz Aitmatov Prosp., Bishkek, the Kyrgyz Republic

e-mail: english@akipress.org, akipressenglish@gmail.com;

Follow us:

Log in


Forgot your password? - recover

Not registered yet? - sign-up

Sign-up

I have an account - log in

Password recovery

I have an account - log in